1st Auto’s toll-free telephone number, (800) 261-2866, is being spoofed by someone else who is calling consumers. We want you to know that 1st Auto staff always leave a message when reaching voicemail, and we do not make any sales calls to consumers. 1st Auto only sells its products via independent insurance agents. If you have received a call and are uncertain whether the caller is actually from 1st Auto, please hang up and call us directly at (800) 261-2866. For more information on spoofing, please go here or contact your state’s office of consumer protection.